I’ve just had the pleasure of helping to judge a short story competition, run jointly by our local arts forum and the local writing group, prizes donated by our local MP. My job was to select the top ten, from which a panel of three decided on the top three prize winners. I enjoyed doing this, partly because the word count was just 500 words : a good enough length for plot and characterisation, and short enough to prevent (hopefully) too much description, too much backstory and too many tangents.
Did they succeed? On the whole, yes! The good stories really stood out for me and these were the features they shared:
I was particularly impressed with the many different ways in which the writers interpreted the theme. Quite a few delved into history, taking true stories or legends and giving them a new slant – very inventive. But there were quite a few, I have to say, where I was struggling to remember what the theme was.
It was extremely hard getting the entries down to just ten: I really wanted to hand over 15, but I couldn’t. So I read them all through for a fourth time, choosing the ones in which I felt there wasn’t a wasted word. Even in 500 words, there were quite a few entries that contained descriptions or backstory that were not, really, necessary. And finally, it was down to the voice – that elusive element that only comes with practice, practice and more practice.
The top three were named in June and I’m pleased that they all appeared in my personal top five!
My hints for competitions:
ps Please do send your comments through the Contacts page. I’m working on how to get them on this page so we can share!